May we have a private party at Mary’s? What about catering?
We do book private parties, but because we're so small, you must reserve the entire restaurant for the whole night. Please give Mary a shout directly with a specific date in mind. We do not cater per se, but are happy to accommodate large orders to go. For orders of 10 items or more, please give us 24 hours notice.
Do you take reservations?
We don't; we're walk-in only. But there are many great bars close by to us, and if you give us your cell number when you come in, you can go around the corner for a drink—we will happily call you when your table is ready.
What if we have a large party (i.e., more than 5 or 6)?
Please just give us a call a day before you would like to bring in your large party and we will do our best to get you in with out a huge wait.
Why do some things sell out because of a limited supply?
Our fish is delivered FRESH six days a week, so running out of supply is a good thing for all of us. Fresh fish!
What should I expect?
Delicious food wrapped in a cozy hustle-bustle.
Do you serve things other than fish?
We do have salads and sides of veggies, but as far as protein goes, we're full-tilt fish.
Why can't we sit and wait for our friends and family to join us?
We could easily fill our tiny restaurant with people waiting but find it best to keep it open for people's eating. Sadly, we can't seat you until your party is complete.
What is your donation policy?
Fishcamp is proud to have made donations to many great causes over the years, including Curtain Call Creations, Greenwich Village Little League, NYU Stern Women in Business, AMFAR AIDS research, Bailey House, Village Community School and the Russell Ferber Memorial (CIA) Fund. We are happy to consider any donation request, but please understand that we cannot accommodate them all.