64 Charles Street
New York, NY 10014 - Map it
(646) 436 2185

Mastercard, Visa, Amex

Open Mon -Sat
Lunch 12pm-3pm
Dinner 6pm-11pm

No Reservations | Take Out Available


Jump to a headline

Paul Liebrandt Picks the Best
Downtown Lobster Roll

Mary’s Fish Camp Lobster Roll
Supremacy Reaffirmed

The Platt 101 Best Restaurants

In summertime, lobster rolls aren’t
just a Maine event. But which is
New York’s best?

Review: Time Out New York

Review: New York Magazine

Review: 10 Best

Review: AOL Cityguide

Review: Time Out New York

A seafood shack that's more
like a diamond than a pearl

Review: Time Out New York

New York Magazine: Roll Playing

Michelin Guide Recommends

ZAGAT Guide Rating

Time Out New York
by Mitchell Davis

After Pearl Oyster Bar partners Mary Redding and Rebecca Charles split up, Redding decided to open her own West Village seafood restaurant. But fans hoping Mary's Fish Camp would alleviate the crunch at Pearl quickly realized they were out of luck: The new restaurant has developed an obsessive fan base of its own, ensuring lines out the door every night-just like at Pearl. Once you get inside, you'll notice that specialties like the Maine-style lobster roll-large chunks of sweet meat suspended in mayonnaise and served in a buttered hot-dog bun with shoestring fries, $18-seem awfully familiar. Still, Mary's Fish Camp isn't identical to Pearl. The new restaurant has a larger kitchen and more tables. (No two pearls are exactly alike, right?) And Mary's menu is more extensive than Pearl's. In fact, some of the best dishes are unique to Mary's. Among them, the lobster knuckles ($9) are a must. The large, meaty pieces, served chilled with drawn butter, form an indispensable part of the eatery's sitting-on-the-dock experience. Don't go thinking this is the second restaurant in a burgeoning chain, though-it doesn't look like reconciliation is on the horizon. When pressed for dirt, the staff at Mary's will only say that a lot of people left Pearl to help Mary out. Dissenters argue that Rebecca is the better cook. Regardless of your allegiances, one thing is for sure: If you want a prime spot in line, you'd better show up early.

Back to Press

© Mary’s Fish Camp & Brooklyn Fish Camp 2012 except press clippings or unless attributed otherwise.
home | menus | press | gift cards | q&a | contact | oyster map | folks we love